Battery Ventures' Consona Tenure: Everybody Wins?

Battery Venture's investment in Consona Corporation was one of the last decade's best returns on investment (ROIs) by any private equity firm investing in enterprise software. And there has been a vehement denial of any presumed trade-off between Consona’s research and development (R&D) investment and making money. TEC principal analyst P.J. Jakovljevic takes a look at how this deal might’ve been a winning proposition for all parties.

Report Preview

In my recent commentary on the merger of CDC Software and Consona Corporation under Vista Equity Partners and under the Aptean name, I was apparently mistaken in nonchalantly speculating that Battery Ventures may not have even broken even on the Consona deal. I have since been set straight by some ex-Consona executives as well as by some private equity (PE) industry insiders and market experts.  

Reportedly, while financial figures cannot be disclosed, Battery's investment in Consona was one of the last decade's best returns on investment (ROIs) by any PE firm that has invested in enterprise software, or anything else for that matter. Moreover, there was a vehement denial of any presumed trade-off between Consona’s research and development (R&D) investment and making money. The PE industry insiders strongly feel that this sort of trade-off can work in the software industry only over the very short term.

PE Industry's Case

Instead, what Battery made on this holding software company is based upon selling the sum of 12 companies for more than it bought them for (in this case, a lot more; in fact, multiple times more). Battery owned Made2Manage ERP for nine years (since 2003). If the vendor had ignored R&D, then how could the product be selling more in the marketplace today than when Battery bought it, and why would Vista pay more for it than Battery had?

According to the aforementioned sources, the secret sauce is simple: the firm ran Consona better. Not all management teams are equal, and it can be easy, in software, to waste R&D dollars on products that no customer cares about. When PE firms are successful, like Battery was on this investment, all they’re really doing is installing better management, which ends up improving the value of the company. The only way you can improve the value of a company is to improve the value to the market of the products and services that it sells, and run it more efficiently, so that it makes more money.

The PE industry insiders acknowledge that many PE firms are not currently making a great return on their software investments. Not everyone can do what Battery did. In fact, Battery’s approach runs against the grain of other PE firms doing software deals. But, make no mistake about it, there is a strong belief that the Consona stint was good for everyone—customers, employees, and investors.

Any PE firm’s success is based in simple economics. If you buy a house and don't take care of it, even in a good real estate market you will probably not get a good return on your investment. But if you make improvements you might get a good return, even in a bad real estate market. Companies are no different.

Read the full report >>

Featured Software Research:

Selecting ERP for Oil and Gas Industry Contractors and Vendors

  • Source: IFS
  • Written By:
  • Published:
Suppliers to the oil and gas industry are under more pressure than ever before to increase quality, collaborate closely with the customer, and take on more project risk. Learn how enterprise resource planning (ERP) helps engineers procure construction companies, equipment fabricators, and service providers to meet the new demands from oil and gas companies. Download this white paper to learn more. Read More

R and SPSS Software: Everyone Wins

  • Source: IBM
  • Written By:
  • Published:
Read this document from IBM to learn why using the R programming language with SPSS Statistics and Modeler software can be better than going it alone with R. Read More

You may also be interested in these related documents:

Strategic Value with Trade Promotion Management A Closed-loop Process for Quick Wins and Profitable Growth

  • Source: SAP
  • Written By:
  • Published:
Here’s the situation: a high-end consumer goods company has achieved tremendous profitability over many years. Although growth is slowing, investors sees potential for much greater growth if the company sells into channels in broader consumer markets. Learn how such a company can achieve its growth objectives by implementing trade promotion management (TPM) software in a way that’s built on best practices. Read More

The SaaS Advantage

More providers of traditional software solutions are moving to software-as-a-service (SaaS) models that meet today’s competitive needs for agility and real-time information, without requiring manufacturers to make a large up-front financial outlay. Confidence continues to increase thanks to pioneering SaaS providers who are able to point to a history of successful implementation. Learn more about the benefits of SaaS. Read More

Beyond Boundaries: A New Role for Finance in Driving Business Collaboration

The current global economic instability means firms have to quickly adapt to business conditions. This uncertainty may increase companies’ reliance on business alliances to provide as-needed skills, services, and products. To optimize these alliances, finance should enter the discussion as early as possible. Find out where finance’s true value lies when realigning strategic objectives to include business collaboration. Read More
comments powered by Disqus