R.
Krause
-
May
26, 2000
Event
Summary
In the wake of last year's highly publicized, extremely embarrassing outages
at their online auction site, eBay has put out for bid a special contract
for its infrastructure/back end. The present supplier, Sun Microsystems,
is not a shoo-in for the contract, and is expected to face stiff competition
in the form of Unix systems from Compaq, HP, and IBM.
The
main eBay servers are Sun's E10000 "Starfire", their largest server product.
IBM will try to beat that with its RS/6000 S80, its high-end Unix server,
which recently has made headlines by surpassing Sun's best transaction-processing
benchmarks.
Although
valuable (we estimate the server price tag at $5-10 million), the contract's
symbolic value exceeds the actual dollars involved. An indication of this
is the dueling PR statements from Sun and IBM: "This is more than a blow
to Sun's advertising campaign," James Sciales, an IBM spokesman, was quoted
regarding their recent big win at Network Solutions Inc. "In Big Blue's
fight to regain market share from Sun for computers that power the Internet,
it's a case study of what IBM is best known for - leading technology."
Sun's
Doug van Aman responded by downplaying the server shift. "IBM sold Network
Solutions one system," he said. "We have many, many, many systems at Network
Solutions. The (Sun) E450 server is a smaller server, while the (IBM)
S80 is their largest server. They won one account, but we still have an
extremely good relationship with Network Solutions."
Beating Sun is a big incentive to its competitors, so the companies are
expending the extra effort to get this particular brass ring.
Market
Impact
The problem with being (or claiming to be) the leader in a market, such
as Web/Internet infrastructure, is that everyone shoots at you. With the
highly visible - and to some, annoying - "we're the dot in dot-com" campaign,
Sun painted a big target on its front, and back, and sides. In recent
months, both IBM (with its RS/6000) and Compaq (with its 64- and 96-CPU
ProLiant configurations) have beaten up Sun's E10000 (Starfire) server
in transaction processing performance.
The
highly embarrassing outages at eBay provided an opportunity for anyone
with a reliability and performance story to take their best shot at prying
Sun loose. The Network Solutions A.root server contract loss adds fuel
to the "Sun is vulnerable" fire. If Sun gets displaced at eBay, the perceived
impact will be far greater than the actual revenue lost - we can envision
rivals referring to Sun as "the not in dot-com". This only increases the
pressure on Sun and its rivals.
In
Sun's defense: the Solaris OS is generally considered highly reliable,
scalable, and powerful, and its users are generally very loyal to it.
There are lots of applications written for it - something IBM/AIX and
HP/HP-UX lack. We also appreciate Sun's tying of pay (for some) to system
uptime - it shows a focus on what's important. We feel the UltraSPARC
II is getting long in the tooth, so it will behoove Sun to get the UltraSPARC
III shipped ASAP. OS loyalty can only carry a product so far; if the hardware
is the cause of lowered performance, customers may find their patience
tested a little too much.
One
point of clarification: although Compaq is in the running for eBay, it
is not the ProLiant series that is being considered, despite the mention
of the ProLiant performance figures earlier. ProLiant is primarily a Windows-based
line. The Compaq products being considered are its NonStop (formerly from
Tandem) servers.
User
Recommendations
The general corporate user will find the eBay dogfight of little interest
(other than intellectual curiosity) in the short term. This is for two
reasons:
- How many can afford multimillion-dollar systems?
- Except for someone who is doing a lot of buying and selling on eBay,
who really cares?
What is of greater interest is the long-term effects:
- If Sun loses eBay and continues to lose big-name accounts, are they
doomed? (We don't think so, but it's not an impossibility.)
- If Sun loses, will they make fundamental changes to their product
structuring, such as reducing prices or making their systems "bullet
proof"? (E10000 transaction unit costs are presently around double those
of an IBM RS/6000 S80. Reliability is often relative, the SunTone program
is long on goals but we'd prefer more specifics like uptime guarantees.)
- Can IBM or Compaq gain credibility as Unix vendors? (HP already has
better Unix market presence than the other two.)
Mainstream customers care about the first two questions, since the answers
may make a difference in their purchasing patterns or the continuity of
operations. Customers may find that the once-compelling Sun "story" is
no longer far enough ahead of the competition to justify the high price
tag. The third question is more for market watchers, and the answer is
more dependent on the number of applications available for each product
line than upon the hardware.
InsideOut Firewall Reporter Unravels the Mysteries of Your Firewall Logs | Top 10 Reasons For Having A Project Kickoff - Part II | Top 10 Reasons For Having A Project Kickoff - Part I | What’s All This Benchmark Stuff, Anyway? | Identix Leads Biometric Authentication | Are ASP Applications Right for You? Part 2: Decision Criteria | Are ASP Applications Right for You?
Part 1: Decision Factors | SCT Corporation Means (e)Business For Process Manufacturing | AMD Hooks Up with Transmeta – For Now | Red Hat Plays 'Love You, Love You Not' with CPUs | Dell Sharpens Its Linux Focus | Prophet 21 First Quarter Revenues Suffer But Pipeline Grows | Palm to Give Developers a Leg Up | Gates Previews Pen-Based Computer | Quantum Snaps Off Its NAS Group |
eMachines to Ship Appliance | What’s in a Name? | Technology Hardware Maintenance-Acquiring and Managing Cost Effective Service | frontpath Announces Mobile Internet Appliance | Transmeta to Intel/AMD: Eat Our Dust | Ariba Holds Announcement Festival | Sun Buys Cobalt | VA Linux Releases NAS Server | How Do You Categorize Notebooks? | IMI Sees Red In Dawn Of Fiscal 2001 | Turmoil in CPU-Land | Red Hat’s Linux Domination Weakens | GNOME Will Try to Buff Up Linux | New Internet Appliances Coming from Compaq | How Do You Categorize Servers? | Compaq to Offer Co-Branded iPAQ BlackBerry Wireless E-mail Solution | Compaq Wins Supercomputer Contract, But Is It Enough? | PC Market Figures Show Compaq, Dell, and HP Lead | Computer Manufacturers Shifting Their Focus to Start-Ups | Rackmount Server Sales Surge | Manhattan Associates Completes Second Quarter On Record Pace | Red Hat Releases Clustering Software | Windows 2000 Bug Fixes Posted | Should It Be Renamed 'Unobtainium'? | Dell Drops WebPC | 21st Century Fox Hunt - US vs. Microsoft | Netpliance’s 4X Price Hike - Will It Spell Boom or Doom? | HP’s LT 6000r Six-CPU Server | Handspring’s Visor Passes Pocket PC | Active Voice Adds Unified Messaging to Cisco’s CallManager | NetWare for Small Business – NetWhy? | New Storage Array from Sun | Compaq to Open Tru64 Unix? | Intraware Acquires Janus for its Extranets | Lucent Receives Engineering Award in Unified Messaging | Technology Project Selection and Management in Community Banks | Dell and Red Hat Form Alliance | At Least It Hasn’t Been Renamed Linux 2001 | Intel 820 Chipset Delays Again, Again, Again… | Cobalt Releases Linux "Clustering" Software | It Takes More Than a Fast CPU to Rule the Web | Compaq’s 'Photon' Comes into the Light | Caldera eDesktop Edges Out Microsoft Windows 2000 in Functionality – Part II | IA-64 Linux From Red Hat | Gateway & AOL Follow Crusoe’s Footprints | Bezos to McNealy: Drop Dead! | MicronPC.com, or, “Where Are They Now?” | Mirapoint Adds Web-Mail Client to Messaging Appliance Line | Network Appliance to Ship Sub-$10K Caching Hardware | Compaq Reorganizes Again | Dell Tops in Customer Satisfaction | Intel Faces 820 Chipset Problems (Again) | Intel Small Server Market | HP “Medals” In U.S. PC Olympics | AMD Server Plans De-Railed | Net Woes for NetWare | Intel Reorganization | It’s a Portal...AND It;s a Gateway | Cooler-running Notebooks from HP, Toshiba, et al. | Netpliance Responds Quickly to Hardware Hack | Intel Server Trends | AMD Earnings Beat the Street! Intel Earnings Beat the Street? | Desktop PCs: Meet the New Boss, Same as the Old Boss… (Dell) | HP e-Vectra Product Follow-up | Dell Updates Its Appliance Line | Apple Displays Its Core in Mac OS X | U.S. vs. Microsoft: Another Day of Reckoning | Why Would Anyone Need More Than 50 IP Addresses? | Will Intel Take a Loss on Each CPU, but Make It Up in Volume? | “Whistler” Beta on the Web? | HP Reorganizes Storage Group, Addresses NAS-cent Market | HP: Why Not Just Call It “e-Vectra.com”? | Compaq Streamlines Product Line | Will MS try the "Open Source" Gambit with WinCE? Why Not – Nothing Else Seems to Work | “It’s a Notebook!” “It’s a Paperweight!” “Wait - It’s Both!” | Cisco: IPv6 is Coming, Eventually | Gosh, There’s a Bug in Windows 98 | Wintel Tries to “Embrace and Extend” the English Language | Information/Internet Appliances | Hewlett-Packard’s NetServer Division – #3 to Get Ready, or #4 to Go? | Palm IPO: 3Com’s morning after, or “Do you know the way to San Jose?” | Does Microsoft Have Something Against 64-Bit Processors? | Acta Technology Helps Add Business Intelligence Capabilities to Major ERP Vendors | Tentative Unification in Server I/O Architecture Battle | Dell Unveils Internet-Enabled Customer Support Strategy | Compaq, Dell Announce Eight-Way Intel Servers | Dell Takes Over the #1 Spot in the U.S. PC Market | Dell to Acquire ConvergeNet International | Gateway Drops AMD | Intel Delays Shipment of 820 Chipset | Flaw in Intel Xeon 550 Chips: Shipments Stopped | Sun to Make Solaris Source Code Available | Palm Tries to Take the Desktop in Hand | MainWin for Linux - NT Apps without NT | TurboLinux Clusters One More Step Taken | Cisco Tries to Cache In By Buying Software Start-Up Tasmania Networks | Intel Throws its "Red Hat" into Linux Ring | NEC Pulls Packard Bell PCs in US | Corel and PC Chips to Accelerate Mass Desktop Deployment of Linux | Gateway, Dell Plan Windows-free Appliances | Here Come the "Information Appliances" | Sony Picks Palm OS | Intel Invests in eSoft - "Lintel" Continues to Grow | AMD Athlon Debuts | EMC to Buy Data General | Compaq to Halt NT on Alpha Development | eMachines Considering Internet Appliance | Sun to "Community Source" Almost Everything | eMachines to Buy FreePC | Dell Jumps Into Internet PC Arena | Be Announces Software Licensing Agreement With Compaq | Acer to Jump on Internet Appliance Bandwagon | Sun's StarPortal Opens Its Gates Early | OS SmackDown! | What If They Shipped an OS and Nobody Came? | Presarios Freezing - and Not Because it's Winter | Intel's "New Best Friend" for Web Appliances is Linux | Compaq Buys a Chunk of Inacom - But Will It Help? | Gateway, Jilted by Intel, Kisses and Makes Up with AMD | Be to Be FreeB(i)e | HP Joins the Athlon Pile-On | Will Sun Burn Linux with "Free" Solaris? | HP says "When in Doubt, Buy It Out" for Server Appliances | Intel Chip Shortage Continuing | Embedded Linux for Handhelds | Linux Laptops from Dell | Come See the Softer Side of Linux? | Windows 2000: Paragon for Partisans, Skewered by Skeptics | Compaq Plans Direct Sales. DTja vu All Over Again? | Goodbye PCs, Hello Appliances? | Intel Tries to Give it Away - AMD Says "No Way" | Linux at 25% of Server OS Market - Is Redmond Hearing Footsteps? | Dell Uses its Muscle to Beat Side-Effects of Taiwan Quake | IBM to Make Cuts in PC Business Real Change, or Just Buying Time? | Micron to Push "Subscriber Computing" Rentals 'R' Us? | Compaq Partners with Red Hat in Linux Support Deal | Bristol Technology Ships Win-to-Lin Migration Tool | Compaq and Samsung in Deal to Save Alpha | Gateway Announces Server Appliances | Dell to Factory-Install Red Hat Linux on Servers | Windows 2000 Releases to Manufacturing - Finally | Catalyst International Ties Fate to SAP | Geac Computer Corporation: Mastering Growth by Acquisitions | Dell's High-End Rackmount Servers - Challenging Compaq's Wintel Dominance | Compaq's High-End Wintel-based Rack Servers - Working Hard to Stay #1 | Compaq's Alpha - Moving Toward Its Omega? | High-End Wintel-Based Rackmount Servers - The Big Get Bigger | IBM's Four-CPU Wintel-Based Rack Servers High Performance, High Cost | HP's Four-CPU Wintel-Based Rack Servers: Focusing on Reliability and Expandability | Dell's 8-CPU Intel Servers Increasing Its Enterprise Focus | Compaq's 8-CPU Intel Servers: the New "Big Iron" | Network Engines, Inc. - Double the CPUs for Web Serving | #2 Dell Tries Harder, Compaq Hurts | Server Appliances - "Caching" In on Internet's Growth |